← Main Menu  |  Book Contents  |  ← Chapter 7  |  Chapter 8  |  Chapter 9 →

The Rise and Fall of The NEW Four Seasons 1966 to 1977

Chapter 8 — The 'Break-Up'

By mid 1977 the Four Seasons were still hopeful of being launched as 'The NEW Four Seasons' with Frankie Valli pursuing a solo career. The group's 'Helicon' album was being used to generate singles as Valli's new solo album was developing. June 15th found 'Down The Hall' issued in the USA but it struggled to make an impact on the Billboard charts. In the UK however it reached #34 in July. The UK record buyers liked the sound of the group without Frankie. But clouds were gathering and nobody realized it would be the last original 'Four Seasons' track to be issued for 4 years. By the end of the year we would wonder what was going on?

Chapter image 1

Lee Shapiro's 1977 cartoon of The New Four Seasons

On 30th June, 'Second Thoughts' PVT111 ( a Paul Anka song) came out in the UK from the 'Lady Put The Light Out' album. The Frankie Valli solo album was not released in the UK (only the USA) although around 200 copies 'escaped' on to the collector's circuit. The single failed to have any chart impact. Frankie wanted Larry Uttal to release 'Native New Yorker' but he refused. As a result the writer Sandy Linzer who had also worked the track with 'Odyssey' (with Charlie Calello) had that version released on RCA. It shot into the US disco charts at #20 and rose to #3 on 26th November for two weeks. On Billboard's chart it reached #21 in February 1978.(#5 in the UK BBC Charts). Although Odyssey's version was superior to Frankie's it was another opportunity lost by Private Stock who instead issued 'I Need You/I'm Gonna Love You' PVT124(45169 in the USA) in October.

Chapter image 2
Chapter image 3

The final positions of the last years Four Seasons output from the USA charts was….“All This And World War II” Album chart #48 (9 weeks on the chart). 'Down The Hall' – Single chart #65 (6 weeks on the chart). 'Helicon' – Album chart #168 (5 weeks on the chart)

'Helicon' was clearly a failure on the US charts but it wasn't the first time a critically acceptable album by the group hadn't sold well. Remember 'Genuine Imitation Life Gazette' and 'Chameleon'. Both, where vehicles for Bob Gaudio's creative output, under the banner of The Four Seasons. Bob wrote 'Helicon' in an attempt to allow the group to take the lead with their career...but with a more 'rock' style: moving on from the concept of 'Who Loves You'....which had a mix of light melodies and funky dance material. That album had created a whole new style and sound. One that had moved from the historical sound of the group....but still retaining strong harmonies on tracks like 'Storybook Lovers' and 'Harmony, Perfect Harmony'. All of the fans could relate to these songs and the new style. So why did 'Helicon' miss 'the spot'.? The fans felt at the time that Bob had un-necessarily abandoned the 'blue-eyed soul' sound that made 'Who Loves You' such a good album. The group had no choice. Once again Bob wasn't learning from the past and mentors like Crewe and Calello, he was simply writing from where he was 'creatively' at the time. The group were brought the tracks as Bob's concept and they did their creative best with them..

The key problem with the style of 'Helicon' was that (unlike the 'Who Loves You' album) it didn't build on the successful style of their 'platinum' album(something Bob Crewe would have done). There were no horns on any of the tracks to sweeten the songs and give it the 'soul' feel. It was different concept:- a synth and piano driven 'rock' sound. The album was a whole new direction that was Bob's idea. Such a gamble is amazing in retrospect. Bob Crewe always knew that the next hit record needed the 'hit sound' during the 60s when he was writing with Bob Gaudio. Gaudio on 'Helicon' didn't consider this or didn't focus sufficiently on what had given them their biggest ever hit. Warner Curb apparently sent Bob Gaudio back to write 'Down The Hall' because they 'couldn't hear a single' and this together with 'Rhapsody' are the closest to the joy and ambition of the 'Who Loves You' album. The problem was also with Warner Curb with their choice of singles and the songs selected for the stage act.

Songs like.....'If We Should Lose Our Love' were solid 'rock' based songs with little 'soul'. The abrupt beat made the song somewhat intense, although brilliantly played . Such songs don't linger in the mind or heart!! Something about simple melodies being best comes to mind, usually Bob Gaudio's forte!

'Lets Get It Right' is one of the better tracks and the playing and singing in the tour performances was superb. (particularly John Paiva's solo.) The problem was the songs, not their interpretation. Don intimates in an interview that the group were not entirely happy with these songs when he says in a 1981 interview;-

“ The beginning of my decision to leave was not so much my having been seduced by having some jingles on the air, as it was….. than after we had success with “Who Loves You”, Bob Gaudio went in and wrote some songs that resembled FM underground hits of who knows how long ago. He insisted on recording them and we put out an album called 'Helicon'. “

Of course some of ‘Helicon’ was very solid like 'Long Ago' which was one song Gaudio kept in the nostalgic / wistful sound reminiscent of the 'Who Loves You' LP...and 'Down The Hall', 'Put A Little Away' and 'New York Street Song'...all give the album a 'core harmony' strength, but Warner Curb couldn't hear the strength amongst these for single release. But the lack of a dance styled track was the big weakness of this album. 'Rhapsody' somehow didn't capture the fans as did 'Who Loves You'. When you have had your 2 biggest hits in a decade with 2 dance beat driven singles then at least keeping the style going was surely good marketing.

Of course although fan clubs had been established in the USA and UK, no-one consulted the fans - a somewhat arrogant approach that the Partnership has always taken. But maybe communications weren't so easy back then. With 'Down The Hall' reaching #34 in the UK charts and the album selling fairly well the group without Valli clearly had a good following.

Lee Shapiro accepted the reality of their position…

”Although we were all glad to be creating more adventurous and intricate music, on 'Helicon' the lyric content wasn't Bob's best (in my opinion). That said, if 'Helicon' had been a big hit, we would have all been "trail blazers". In hindsight, we all commented that we would have liked to have followed up the style of "Dec. 63". But, we (as employees…my words ..ed) bore no risk, creatively or financially. Who wouldn't have followed Bob's lead?”

Regarded as a musical genius Bob commanded respect and he got that from this group and for this album.

John Paiva recollections of the album and of the group show this with some reservations….

“I would love to say something intelligent and insightful, but frankly, I totally enjoyed working in the studio, and fully accepted what ever songs Bob presented. After all, when all was said and done, he called all the shots and I felt that he was certain of himself and all his decisions. It was years later when I came to realise that he like most humans, had his doubts. On the other hand, I do not believe he was interested in my opinion, or input. I did believe that he respected me as the guitarist and pulled the best out of me when my time came for the solos and overdubs. I particularly enjoyed when we worked alone with Steve Maslow in the studio on most of my stuff. Steve gave his full attention and I felt he did his best to get my best. The one time, when Bob Gaudio edited my solo was when we had recorded with a couple of the Seasons in the booth, and they were enthusiastic about something I played. I felt that he resented comment and simply chose another direction based on the fact that he was the boss. Perhaps I misread that, but everyone has their opinion, and that is mine.
Chapter image 4

John Paiva and Don Ciccone, Radio City Music Hall October 1977; Photo Frank Rovello

Generally speaking I really loved the Helicon album. Gerry sang so well on 'NYC Street Song' which is one of my favourites. The other unappreciated guitarist was Tim Breen. This guy was a genius musician who brought tremendous energy into the studio. Sad to say Tim passed away years ago although he was only a young man. I feel rather obligated to his memory as his presence in the studio kept me at my best. He was also extraordinarily supportive and wonderful to work with. I personally considered him a fifth Season.”

The album however really needed at least 3 better songs to tie the good album tracks together....but the lack of a really strong hit single seems to have blown Warner Curb's commitment and they wouldn't commission another album with the group especially without Valli. His contribution although slight is still superb on 'Put A Little Away', 'New York Street Song” and 'I Believe In You'. . The group's performance on the album is totally professional and competent….and although the songs lack the spark of before this was still a good album…just not a great one.

Looked at today the album is a much stronger collection and was probably ahead of its time. It has taken a long time for it to become available to the world wide fan base on CD.

Chapter image 5

Artwork from inside sleeve of the 'Helicon album

With the lack of positive response in the USA to solo performances by the group and the poor showing of 'Helicon' Bob and Frankie were beginning to think the launch of the group on their own could be a financial disaster. There was no next record deal with Warner-Curb. However the success in Europe and Australia of the group seemed lost in the 'ether'. The 'harmony' the fans believe existed between the group and Gaudio and Valli was only a PR image it is now clear.

By August things were still not settled and UK fan club chairman John Riley discussed the situation with Bob Gaudio on a UK visit to reveal indecision about the way forward. He hinted at the problem for Frankie. …”I think a lot of people will have great difficulty in identifying with the 4 Seasons without Frankie”, said John. Bob replied

….”Yes they will. But this is one of the things that we will be taking into consideration. I have a feeling though that Frankie will always be somewhere around the 4 Seasons. It's in his blood.”

Poor record sales put the future of the group, in the economic climate at the time, at risk. In the UK in 1977 unemployment had risen to over 1.1 million, the highest since 1940 and inflation was standing at 24 percent. New York was nearly declared bankrupt and the economic climate was not good. Surprising given that the music industry had been booming in the previous 2 years and the LP was in it's zenith. Travis Elborough in The Long-player Goodbye captures this:-

“Whatever the underlying economic current, the music industry had, by now, become a global business dominated by multinationals. Just two years earlier, 'Time' had reported that sales of records and tapes had spiked to nearly $2 billion, and $3.3 Billion worldwide, making music 'the most popular form of entertainment in America'. 'With such sales', the book continues, 'no wonder the conglomerates are conglomerating in the record business. …..everyone was trying to buy up a label and go from wax to riches'. At the end of that year, seven majors (CBS, Capitol, MCA, Warners, Polygram, RCA, and A&M) …..had consolidated their grip on the industry. Two giants, CBS and Warner, by then accounted for nearly 40% of all the records produced in the US. Similarly, by 1975 six multi-nationals (EMI, CBS, Polygram, Warners, RCA and Decca) were bagging over two thirds of the British Record market”

These companies thought big …and sales where big. Elton John's 'Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy' sold 1.4 million copies in the first four days of its release in the USA.. Walter Yetnikof of CBS group informed press around this time that

“if an artist can only sell 100,000 records, then this company is not interested in pursuing that artist. We are looking for the major, major breakthroughs”

Frankie Valli's plans had been put in place earlier in the year to produce a new 'solo' album with Charles Calello arranging. The album 'Lady Put The Light Out' PS7002 was issued only in the USA even though designed to launch his 'solo' career. Charles Calello said of the album…

”'Lady Put The Light Out' was mostly Frankie. Frankie started taking more control. He also picked most of the songs. Crewe was in a serious accident around that time and I don't think Frankie wanted Gaudio to produce him because Gaudio was 'cold'. He hadn't produced a 'solo' hit for him in many years”

(He had also failed to generate any hits on the 'Valli' album a year before, although this was down to poor promotion)

Chapter image 6
Chapter image 7

The confusion at Private Stock is well illustrated by the two very different album covers to the same album. On the left the US album cover and right the UK (unreleased) album of which around 200 copies appeared.

“… and Frankie had had three hits in a row in 1976 with other producers. Maybe he felt it was time for him to do his own thing. The key song on that album was "Native New Yorker." However, it wasn't a hit by Frankie, it was a hit by another group on RCA, Odyssey. There was one other song we were going to record but the arrangement was left with the copyist and he never found it. "I'd Rather Leave While I'm In Love." The arrangement subsequently turned up and this song although performed frequently in concert was never recorded and released.”

(ed...as far as we know in 2026). Bob Gaudio had no involvement in the album and was distracted by a commission to produce Neil Diamond's latest album.

But there was trouble brewing at Private Stock. The Vice –president's resignation left Valli without a big supporter and stories of financial trouble were surfacing. The difficult economic climate saw sales collapsing and record companies under threat.

As fans expected a launch of the two entities - Valli 'Solo' and The NEW Four Seasons' the last performance 'together'…a sort of 'Farewell Concert' was planned for 7/8th October 1977

Photo Montage from Farewell Concerts on 7th and 8th October at Radio City Music Hall courtesy of Frank Rovello

Chapter image 8

at Radio City Music Hall. But the writing was on the wall by then. No songs were played at the shows from the 'Helicon' album as the band was going to be 'no more'. Frankie Valli's solo songs from his current album 'Lady Put The Light Out ' were featured and USA fan club reps (Steve Bailey) met Frankie and his manager who assured him that the communications with the fan club organization would be maintained. But this was not the final show. Several shows followed ( these later shows being re-organised from August cancellations.) and the whole winding –up process ended in Las Vegas at the Aladdin on 22nd November 1977

The break up when it happened is simply a story of redundancy……which many people in many industries will relate to……. Like any redundancy it knocks the employee for six….. John Paiva again in his personal biography……..

“When in 1977 Frankie decided that he wanted to go out as a single. I was somewhat surprised, but thought..... swell! The Four Seasons will do just fine without Frankie. We could go out as an opening act until the audience got used to us appearing without Frankie, then perhaps another Warner Brothers album. We had just recently finished 'Helicon' which was a great album. The Four Seasons Partnership would reap financial rewards on us as well as Frankie's new endeavours. We would all make loads of money. Wouldn't we? ......I mean to say, we are STARS,....ain´t we?!? .... The answer, my naive fool, is NO NO NO and double NO!! It's a plan....... Are you blind!? These guys have talked it out..... The contract you signed says clearly that if you should no longer be associated with the Four Seasons partnership, you were never to perform using the name The Four Seasons etc. In other words.................... Read the SMALL PRINT ................ Schmuck!! It was an old song, only this time it was being sung to me. This all took place while we were headlining at the Riviera Hotel in Vegas. Good, eh!? ............ Headlining!! So Frankie says: “I'm going out as a single“. I figure we will go on. After all that was the plan he had talked about. He says: “Naturally, the checks will stop”....... I say: “HUH!?!” Oh well. .....That's O.K.!! Anonymous Management (Alan Carr) will get us work opening for some people for a while till we are on our feet. Alan's representative Dennis Pregnalato says: “We won't be managing you.” “HUH!?!” I figure, I'm missing something. I'm getting screwed and this time it's no fun. It was then, I finally became aware of how little I meant to these people. I childishly thought of us as a family. I didn't realise that our family was dysfunctional. I was in a whirl. The last four days in Las Vegas were eventful emotionally. It was our final show night, we'd been given the word that we were finished as a group and feeling somewhat shell-shocked we went on with the show. Being final night someone in the band decided to play a joke on Frankie. I personally would have preferred them to hire a 'hit-man' given what we had been told. A hooker was hired to be on the front row for 'My Eyes Adored You'…a well-endowed lady 'up-top' and her ample 'attributes' were resting on the edge of the stage as everyone stood up. By the time the song started they had somehow become 'exposed'!! But give Frankie his due, he was note perfect!.....maybe he was blinded by the stage lights!....... There was a farewell party........After four years of touring together it was over.........No exchange of gifts..... No fond hand shakes or good wishes.............................Pretty much a kick out the door. I had been so involved in this organisation that I was in a slight state of shock. It seemed unreal. It was evident that The Partnership had been working on this plan for some time. Although there was a contract stating that we were not to use the name, I wanted to do just that. I spoke with the others. They were not into it, claiming that the contract was solid. Sure it was. Still if we had immediately gone to another agency we would certainly have been picked up. Then after our first show The Partnership would have sued us and we would be headlines. Then we could change our name to The New 4 Seasons and off we would go..... but no-one was willing to.
Chapter image 9
After all is said and done, it was a gas being a member of the Seasons. We traveled and I had a wonderful time. Unfortunately as time wore on Frankie and I seemed more and more to be at odds with each other. He resented my being overweight, but I was that way when he made me a member of the organisation. That is not an excuse. It is a fact. I didn't dislike him because he is short. (On the other hand it is probably easier to lose weight than to get taller.) Frank loved saying: “You should wallow in your success!” I suppose he meant well. The fact was that although we were with a successful group and individually very well known, we were hardly pulling down a R&R stars money. I can never forget playing Madison Square Garden and, as I worked stage right, we entered stage left. I was the first to go across. Imagine my feeling when 22,000 people there screamed my name. I think that qualifies me as at least a pretty well known artist. Yet at the same time I knew that I was as always on a small weekly allowance on the road as our wages were not great and money was tight”

The fan club Newsletters show that no explanation was given for the disbanding of the group. And speaking to some of the former Four Seasons around 2009 it appears they were as surprised as the fans. The plan to launch them as a NEW group was developed in 1975 and Frankie Valli had gradually distanced himself from the line-up as he pursued his solo career. But it appears the investment in the group, after the failure of 'Helicon' and the state of the music industry, was not something Bob and Frankie were prepared to do and it was left to the group themselves. No management support…no song-writing for them……no, lets try another album together…..Frankie and Bob, their employers simply pulled the plug.

Of course Bob and Frankie could argue that the bestowing of 'stardom' was as a result of them employing them in the first place and they would be right. But creating a quality band, the “best ‘Four Seasons’ ever musically” and then simply sacking them defies logic. Why they couldn't just continue to work as the Four Seasons remains a mystery only Frankie can explain and his ego trip to be a ‘solo’ artist. He would learn another ‘hard lesson’ in his turbulent life.

So from being 'stars' these four talented musicians simply found themselves being 'made redundant'. Anecdotal information says that Warner Bros wanted to sign them as a group but with no access to their name which was owned by the Partnership, they had no identity and the disillusionment had destroyed any togetherness that existed and held them together. Just another failed rock-band. ! Four musicians looking for gigs.! And the personal upset from the split is still apparent when I talked to John Paiva 33 years after the event.

The real reason why? Well we can only speculate but fears raised by Frankie and Bob's lawyer Peter Bennett that the Partnership could lose control of the name 'The Four Seasons' are probably at the core of it. The group's success without Valli created this risk and self-protection became paramount. Also keeping the two businesses separate and managing them could have made for future conflict and it was an investment Bob and Frankie simply didn't want to make. The Partnership retained and controlled the band name…'The Four Seasons'. They do to this day.

So Frankie Valli was now 'solo' and he had no competition from 'The NEW Four Seasons' and he could shape the next stage of his career.

We, the fans however had “disastrously lost 'our' NEW Four Seasons”…..but there would be an 'aftermath'. What would happen to the dedicated fans of the US and UK fan clubs?. Could Frankie Valli survive as a ‘solo’ artist. Bad decisions make good stories, as this chapter shows…..and as 1978 beckons and life goes on, business is business for The Partnership and there is still money (and music) to be made.

The group from the Farewell Concerts at Radio City Music Hall courtesy of Frank Rovello

Chapter image 10

Chapter References/Credits

Goldmine Article – The Four Seasons - A Lesson in Survival by Rex Woodard 1981: Article From A Warner Bros Circular November 1984 by Joshua Baer Titled “4 Seasons To Consider”; “Out Of Season” by John Paiva (unpublished biography); Four Seasons UK Appreciation Society Newsletters: Special thanks to: Charles Calello: Lee Shapiro: Frank Rovello: Ken Charmer: George Ingram: Lynn Boleyn: Ray Nichol: Malcolm Grace; Brian Lomas